Former New York Yankees All-Star shortstop Derek Jeter is still making headlines even after retiring from baseball more than a year ago. He recently announced his engagement to Sports Illustrated model Hannah Davis after three years of dating.

The New York sports icon has been romantically linked to some A-list ladies over the years, including Jessica Biel, Mariah Carey and Minka Kelly. Jeter appeared this week on Undeniable, a show hosted by Joe Buck that airs on the Audience Network.

As you might imagine, Buck and Jeter discussed some of the great rumors involving the former Yankees captain, including the "gift basket" episode. Almost like something out of Seinfeld, the New York Post once reported that Jeter gave out gift baskets to all of his one-night stands, which included a signed baseball.